Melanie Martinez Cry Baby Perfume Milk Dupes & Alternatives
Melanie Martinez Cry Baby Perfume Milk Dupes & Alternatives
Isn’t it frustrating when your favourite perfume gets discontinued, leaving you longing for that signature scent? Fans of Melanie Martinez‘s Cry Baby Perfume Milk know this all too well. This distinctive fragrance blends dark fruity notes with strawberry milk and a lipstick accord, then deepens into a nostalgic mix of baby lotion, wrapped in burnt caramel and mysterious woods—complex and memorable.
Sadly, Cry Baby Perfume Milk is no longer in production. In a 2023 interview, Melanie revealed that a restock isn’t possible since the original manufacturer has closed. However, there’s still hope for a reissue, hinted at by the CEO of Portals Parfums. As we await its return, the perfume’s lasting presence will continue to linger in our minds.
Missing this scent? Don’t worry—we at Beautinow have you covered with a curated list of fantastic dupes and alternatives to keep you smelling wonderful until Cry Baby makes a comeback. Ready to explore nostalgic scents and exciting new finds? Let’s dive in!
Yes I Am by Cacharel
If you’re drawn to bold statement pieces, you’ll love the Yes I Am perfume by Cacharel. Right off the bat, its lipstick-shaped bottle in vivid red and smoked black glass makes it a standout on any dresser. Launched in 2018 by the talented duo Honorine Blanc and Christophe Raynaud, this fragrance is all about embracing the femme fatale of today—confident, daring, and unapologetically romantic.
The scent kicks off with a lively mix of tangerine, raspberry, bergamot, and lemon. As it settles, you’ll catch the floral and slightly spicy heart notes of ginger flower, gardenia, jasmine, and more, leading to a warm, inviting base of cardamom, milk, and a dash of vanilla, caramel, and licorice. It’s a bit spicier and has a zesty opening, thanks to the ginger and bergamot, making it a great pick if you’re missing the vibe of Cry Baby Perfume Milk but don’t mind a twist. At €37 for a 30ml bottle, it’s a more wallet-friendly alternative to chasing down overpriced bottles of Cry Baby on eBay or Etsy.
No 52 Sweet Strawberry Milk by MIIM: MIIC Fragrance Laboratories
The buzz around Melanie Martinez’s Cry Baby Perfume Milk just keeps growing, and fragrance brands are jumping in to fill the void with cool, wallet-friendly dupes. MIIM: MIIC Fragrance Laboratories is right there with them, introducing No 52 Sweet Strawberry Milk—a scent that nods to Cry Baby’s unique vibe. But they didn’t stop there; they’re also offering No 52 as a hand cream, a diffuser oil, and a roll-on perfume. Fans are loving it, though they say it’s a tad more floral than the original. There’s even a hint of Marc Jacobs’s Daisy mingling in there, which turns out to be a neat twist for most who’ve tried it. While it can’t quite match the powerhouse projection and sillage of the original (Cry Baby really is something else!), it’s still a solid pick. And at €55.95 for 50ml, it’s a steal that’ll keep you reminiscing about Cry Baby.
Masque Milano Lost Alice Eau De Parfum
Masque Milano Lost Alice Eau de Parfum
£28,08 £160,82Price range: £28,08 through £160,82Masque Milano Lost Alice Eau De Parfum is an excellent alternative to “Melanie Martinez Cry Baby Perfume Milk” because of its distinctive milk base note. This note provides a creamy, comforting undertone similar to Cry Baby Perfume Milk, but with added aromatic complexity. The inclusion of sandalwood and broom in the base adds a rich, aromatic depth, making it ideal for those seeking a more sophisticated and layered scent experience.
Sweet Tooth by Sabrina Carpenter
From one singer to another, we’re buzzing about this fab alternative to Cry Baby by Sabrina Carpenter. Sweet Tooth is all about sweet, vanilla vibes with a spicy twist that’s just as intriguing as its packaging. Yep, the bottle is shaped like a pink chocolate bar and it’s honestly hard to resist. Like Cry Baby, Sweet Tooth is, well, sweet—but it swings a bit more floral with a gentle jasmine heart. The spark of candied ginger right at the start gives Sweet Tooth a lively zing on the first spritz.
What really stands out is its bold marshmallow note, enhancing the vanilla base the longer it lingers on your skin. If Cry Baby’s signature lipstick and strawberry combo isn’t always your jam, Sweet Tooth might just hit the sweet spot with its similar but distinct twist. It’s a gorgeously sweet and cosy scent, and it punches above its weight in longevity and projection, especially for a celeb perfume. Priced at €41 for a 30ml bottle, it’s a sweet deal that fits right into the same price range as Yes I Am. While Yes I Am suits a broad audience, from young adults to the grown crowd, Sweet Tooth has a youthful edge, so it’s worth a sniff before you dive in.
Les Bains Guerbois Damier Eau De Parfum
Les Bains Guerbois Damier Eau de Parfum
Original price was: £178,69.£101,26Current price is: £101,26.Damier Eau de Parfum by Les Bains Guerbois is an excellent alternative to Melanie Martinez Cry Baby Perfume, due to its unique milk heart note. While it shares this creamy, comforting essence, “Damier Eau de Parfum” adds a sophisticated twist with its spicy and peppery top notes of Black Pepper and Pink Pepper. This blend of traditional elegance and modern boldness makes it a perfect choice for those seeking a more vibrant and dynamic fragrance experience.
Strawberry Milk! Perfume Oil By Sugar Milk Co
Strawberry Milk! strikes a delightful balance between a dupe and a unique alternative. It echoes Cry Baby’s DNA, yet enriches it with a creamier, more vanillic twist that gourmand fragrance enthusiasts will adore. Based in Texas, Sugar Milk Co is earnestly carving a niche for itself amongst countless dupe producers. They’ve formulated Strawberry Milk!, along with most of their products, to be gentle on both skin and hair, making it an excellent choice as a body scent, hair fragrance, and moisturiser—all in one.
This perfume oil from Sugar Milk Co is made with phthalate-free fragrance oils and is alcohol-free, characteristics that often mean the scent lasts longer on the skin. Available in either a 50ml spray bottler or a 10ml roll-on, this perfume oil comes at €45.95 (50ml bottle). While slightly pricier than some alternatives precisely because it is a perfume oil, fans nevertheless insist the superior quality, enticing scent, and robust projection make it a worthy investment.
Fraise Fouettée by Le Monde Gourmand
Fraise Fouettée captures the essence of a perfect strawberry milkshake with a delightful tropical twist. If you’re after a playful variation on Cry Baby, this scent adds an exotic mix of coconut water and banana notes to the blend. It’s also infused with a floral touch, thanks to a heart of heliotrope, enhancing its complexity. One whiff and you’ll be transported to a scene of ripe strawberries, freshly plucked and basking in a velvety mix of vanilla cream and whipped sugar—an enchanting dance of tart and sweet.
Bright, playful, and absolutely irresistible, Fraise Fouettée is a sensory delight, leaving a tingling sensation with every spritz. There’s a subtle powdery note here too, a favourite feature for fans of Cry Baby. Priced at only €46 for a 30ml bottle, Fraise Fouettée offers an affordable and delectable alternative that’s just perfect for your next beach getaway.
Juicy Couture Viva La Juicy Pink Couture Eau De Parfum
Juicy Couture Viva La Juicy Pink Couture can’t be classified as a Cry Baby perfume dupe. However, it’s definitely a great alternative due to its fruity character and its strawberry heart note. But that’s not the only thing this fragrance has in common with Cry Baby Perfume Milk. The overlapping vanilla and woody provide a similar ambery finish. This makes it the perfect per excellent choice for those who love fruity, yet sophisticated fragrances.
Strawberry Milkshake by ALT. Fragrances
Strawberry Milkshake by ALT. Fragrances is a standout among dupes, capturing the essence of the elusive and now-discontinued Cry Baby Perfume Milk. Known for replicating the hottest scents on the market, ALT. Fragrances has crafted this fragrance as a tribute to a blend of whimsical innocence and edgy rebellion.
The scent journey starts with an alluring burst of dark fruits that set a mysterious tone, quickly followed by a playful note of strawberry milk mingled with a distinctive lipstick accord. This combination dances between sweet allure and intriguing seduction. The heart brings a rush of nostalgia with a soft baby lotion accord, echoing cherished memories with a mischievous wink. It culminates in a base of rich burnt caramel and mysterious woods, adding depth and maturity.
Strawberry Milkshake offers more than just a scent—it’s a celebration of playful memories with a sophisticated twist. Handcrafted in the USA, and committed to clean, vegan, and cruelty-free products in fully recyclable bottles, this perfume offers charisma and conscience. Priced at €46 for a 60ml bottle, Strawberry Milkshake delivers exceptional value, making it a must-try for anyone yearning for Cry Baby’s charm without the steep price tag. Whether you’re filling a void or just craving a nostalgic scent, this dupe is too good to pass up.
The Spirit Of Dubai Majalis Eau De Parfum
The Spirit of Dubai Majalis Eau de Parfum
Original price was: £361,63.£246,76Current price is: £246,76.The Spirit of Dubai Majalis Eau De Parfum is a great alternative to Cry Baby Milk Perfume due to its similar fragrance profile. Majalis features a fruity strawberry top note that offers a sweet and inviting scent, while its woody vanilla base notes provide a warm and comforting finish. These elements make it a comparable and appealing choice for those who enjoy Cry Baby Milk Perfume.
Oh Baby! by The Dua Brand
We simply can’t wrap up this fabulous listicle without featuring a fragrance from The Dua Brand, a major player in the perfume dupes market. Among their offerings, they have a delightful Cry Baby dupe named Oh Baby!.
Oh Baby! offers a more accessible option for those enchanted by the decadent sweetness of amber vanilla. While the original Cry Baby was known for its unique baby milk bottle presentation and steep price, Oh Baby! lets you enjoy a similar gourmand thrill without the hefty cost. The fragrance blends notes of milk, strawberry, forest fruits, powdery elements, caramel, and wood to create a captivating scent. It opens with a burst of irresistible strawberry, enhanced by sweet, creamy caramel. As it develops, powdery and lactonic notes mingle, evoking the comforting aroma of fresh strawberry milk.
Fans of Oh Baby! rave about its yummy scent, particularly the subtle guava note that melds beautifully with the perfume’s powdery, milky, and woody tones. The caramel base is also a standout, making Oh Baby! a quintessential fruity gourmand fragrance, much like its inspiration, Cry Baby. Priced at €51 for a 34 ml bottle, it’s a bit of a splurge but far more affordable compared to the elusive €1000 Cry Baby bottles currently on the market.
We hope this collection of scents helps fill the void left by the beloved Cry Baby Perfume Milk. Each of these alternatives offers its own unique charm, ensuring you can keep your scent game strong and exciting. Whether you’re drawn to the creamy richness of Strawberry Milk! or the playful zest of Sweet Tooth, there’s something here to ignite your senses and spark memories. Dive into these fragrances to find your new signature scent. Remember to sample these delightful alternatives and embrace the journey to discovering your next favourite perfume. Embrace the adventure, and let your fragrance tell your story!
This is an amazing list! Thank you for all you do lol